I was pleased to receive the other day the following wry email: You’ve inspired me since your presentation to our firm back in May. I used to be content with my drafting before I met you, but I now live in constant internal turmoil. My correspondent’s state of mind comes as no surprise. To master contract language, first you have … Read More
[Update October 18, 2009: This post has been supplanted by this new post. I’ll be deleting this post in the next few days.] [Revised 12:45 p.m. EDT to mention, at the end of this post, a relevant May 2009 blog post.] In my post on the AAA standard arbitration clause, I reiterated my doubts about the relating to part of … Read More
While at a social event in Saratoga recently, I had the pleasure of meeting Jerry Kaplan, senior counsel in McDermott Will & Emery’s Chicago office. Ever the imaginative conversationalist, I turned the topic to—what else?—contract drafting. At some point in our conversation Jerry wondered whether contracts wouldn’t be more efficient if drafters were able to refer to a standard set of … Read More
[Updated 16 September 2024: Go here for my New York Law Journal article based on this post. It’s different, and better! And I’ve decided that the consenting language in the NYLJ article is redundant, for reasons explained in this 2021 blog post.] [Revised Aug. 30 7:20 p.m. EDT to reflect comments by Mark and Richard; revised further Oct. 18 with respect to “arising … Read More
No one has ever mentioned to me MSCD chapter 13 (Numbers and Formulas) or asked me any questions about it, so evidently the subject isn’t high on anyone’s list of concerns. But I have a soft spot for that chapter anyway—it discusses the fiendishly subtle forms of ambiguity that can arise in expressing formulas in prose and mathematical equations, and … Read More
[Updated 7 February 2021] A standard way of giving notice under a contract is by overnight delivery by FedEx or one of its competitors. To articulate this notion, many drafters use the word courier, with varying degrees of specificity. For example, the phrase nationally recognized overnight courier occurs in 204 contracts filed on Edgar last month as Exhibit 10 material contracts. … Read More
Reader Jason recently posted the following comment to my April 2007 post on including without limitation: I just ran across an instance of including with limitation XXX. I couldn’t determine if with limitation meant: only; that XXX is included, but with limitations on what parts of XXX are included; or things that are limited, and XXX is one example of … Read More
[Updated January 5, 2011] Now that my summer is officially over … I suspect that many drafters think that an indemnification section should appear in contracts as a matter of course, much like a governing-law provision. But before you include an indemnification section, consider the pros and cons. Indemnification Can Benefit a Party Bringing a Claim Bring In Deep Pockets. … Read More
[Revised Aug. 21 to reflect comments by Mark, Paul, and Pete] I interrupt my August recess to consult you all on how I should define “Government Body”. Here’s what I’ve come up with : “Government Body” means (1) the government of any country or of any political subdivision of any country, (2) any instrumentality of any such government, (3) any … Read More
I’m looking forward to August. I’ll be spending time in Cap Ferret, on France’s west coast; in Geneva, Switzerland; and in Saratoga Springs, in upstate New York. I’ll enjoy showing my daughter a bit of Europe (including Geneva, the city where she was born) and having her get reacquainted with family members she sees too infrequently. She’s already insisting that one … Read More
